... the FTC has now appealed its Qualcomm case to the full Ninth Circuit. Thursday, February 13, 2020. Share. Kieren McCarthy in San Francisco Tue 25 Aug 2020 // 20:37 UTC. Video of FTC v. Qualcomm Oral Argument It's available here, starting about thirty minutes in. The FTC argued Qualcomm applied an excessive "surcharge" to phone makers, charging them too high a price for patent licenses because the phone makers had to sign the deals to get Qualcomm's chips. Appeals judges toss out FTC win: What Qualcomm did to its rivals was 'hypercompetitive, not anticompetitive' An appeals court has reversed an earlier ruling that Qualcomm broke America's antitrust laws, dealing a blow to the FTC, which brought the case. At the heart of these proceedings lies Qualcomm’s so-called “No License, No Chips” (NLNC) policy, whereby it purportedly refuses to sell chips to OEMs that have not concluded a license agreement covering its underlying intellectual property. 2020 Hyundai Tucson Review. On August 11, 2020, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in favor of Cravath client Qualcomm Incorporated, a leading innovator of cellular technology, in its appeal from an adverse California federal court decision in an antitrust lawsuit filed by the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”). Qualcomm Incorporated includes Qualcomm's licensing business, QTL, and the vast majority of its patent portfolio. On November 22, the FTC filed its answering brief in the FTC v. Qualcomm litigation. Qualcomm’s procompetitive justification is supported by at least two other companies—Nokia and Dolby—with similar SEP portfolios to Qualcomm’s.17 More critically, this part of the FTC’s argument skips ahead 17 See Br. Decision Reversing FTC v. Qualcomm August 27, 2020 . FTC urged to fight Qualcomm decision 25 AUG 2020 Ford, Daimler, Intel and MediaTek were among a group of 21 which pleaded for the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to contest a successful legal appeal by Qualcomm overturning a patent licensing decision. U.S. FTC Moves for Rehearing of Qualcomm Antitrust Defeat More FILE PHOTO: A Qualcomm sign is shown outside one of the company's many buildings in San Diego, California, U.S., September 17, 2020. Re: Future standards . The FTC argued Qualcomm applied an excessive “surcharge” to phone makers, charging them too high a price for patent licenses because the phone makers had to sign the deals to get Qualcomm’s chips. The Federal Trade Commission today filed a petition with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit requesting rehearing en banc of the August 11, 2020, decision of a panel of that court in the matter of FTC v. Qualcomm Incorporated.. The panel held that Qualcomm’s conduct—(a) refusing to license its standards essential patents (SEPs) to rival chipset Qualcomm appealed the FTC ruling, and on August 9, 2020, the U.S. Ninth District Court reversed the FTC decision, vacating the injunction against Qualcomm’s licensing model. Monday, September 28, 2020. The appeals court called Qualcomm’s behavior “hypercompetitive,” but not anticompetitive. The Vergecast discusses Apple’s announcement of their AirPods Max noise-canceling headphones, then talks with Qualcomm president Cristiano Amon about the Snapdragon 888. ©2021 Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. and/or its affiliated companies. Without a doubt, optimism was needed when the FTC sued Qualcomm in 2017, claiming that the chipmaker collected royalties from some of its patents in an anticompetitive manner. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) just can’t take “no, you’re wrong” for an answer. FTC's "No License-No Chips" theory in Qualcomm case may have been too aggressive to be affirmed For the technology industry, the question of whether rival chipset makers are entitled to a FRAND license to Qualcomm's cellular standard-essential patents (SEPs) is the commercially most relevant part of the case. ... 2020 6:17 pm. Qualcomm appealed the ruling with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in July 2019 and received a ruling in their favor this year. 5G, FTC Appeal Could be Catalysts to Take Qualcomm Stock to New Highs Despite recent run-up, further upside remains even as QCOM stock approaches 52-week mark By Thomas Niel Jan 21, 2020… February 2020 Security Bulletin Version 1.0 Published: 02/03/2020. FTC unable to explain how Qualcomm's terms impacted rivals Court sides with Qualcomm in FTC's appeal of dismissed antitrust case Oct. 28, 2020 2:22 PM ET QUALCOMM Incorporated (QCOM) By: Brandy Betz , SA News Editor 26 Comments I watched the beginning of the argument this morning, then had to break for an event, and am about to resume. Some rival chip firms and industry trade groups that supported the FTC's initial antitrust lawsuit against Qualcomm in 2017 signed this latest letter as well, including Intel and ACT/The App Association. References to "Qualcomm" may mean Qualcomm Incorporated, or subsidiaries or business units within the Qualcomm corporate structure, as applicable. Qualcomm is currently in the midst of a high-profile antitrust case against the FTC. 2020 Kia Forte Review ... We also know that Apple and Samsung had a "common interest" agreement to work closely with FTC. On Wednesday, October 28, a US appeals court declined to reconsider a decision that dismissed the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) antitrust case against Qualcomm, reported the Wall Street Journal. The FTC's case was backed by Apple, which filed its own US antitrust lawsuit against Qualcomm. ... Thursday 13th August 2020 03:31 GMT Anonymous Coward. I may have some thoughts later today or tomorrow. Intel, HP, Tesla and a host of other tech giants have written to America's Federal Trade Commission (FTC) urging it to appeal Qualcomm's legal win against the watchdog in a row over patent fees. So apparently Chairman Simon, who is no longer recused in the matter, parted company with his two Republican colleagues on this issue. ... Oct 17, 2020 | Top Stories, U.S. This security bulletin is intended to help Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. (QTI) customers incorporate security updates in launched or upcoming devices. - Aug. 11th 2020 9:56 am PT @michaelpotuck ... business practices were anticompetitive in a case brought by the Federal Trade Commission. But a handful of auto companies—Tesla, Honda, Ford and Daimler—joined this time in asking commissioners to keep up the battle. Copy. More on FTC v. Qualcomm The FTC itself released this press release, stating that the vote to proceed with a petition for rehearing en banc was 3-2. In 2017, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission sued Qualcomm for violating both sections of the Sherman Antitrust Act by engaging in a number of anticompetitive SEP licensing practices. Coverage of federal case FTC v. Qualcomm Inc., case number 19-16122, from Appellate - 9th Circuit Court. On August 11, 2020, a Ninth Circuit panel reversed the District Court for the Northern District of California ’s judgment in FTC v. Qualcomm, Inc. Or subsidiaries or business units within the Qualcomm corporate structure, as applicable its affiliated companies, QTL and... Ruling in their favor this year within the Qualcomm corporate structure, as applicable had to break for an,. Unable to explain how Qualcomm 's licensing business, QTL, and am about to resume with Ninth. Qualcomm '' may qualcomm ftc 2020 Qualcomm Incorporated, or subsidiaries or business units within Qualcomm! Longer recused in the FTC v. Qualcomm August 27, 2020 13th August 2020 03:31 GMT Anonymous Coward about resume! Event, and the vast majority qualcomm ftc 2020 its patent portfolio agreement to work closely with.! 11Th 2020 9:56 am PT @ michaelpotuck... business practices were anticompetitive in a case brought the... With his two Republican colleagues on this issue impacted rivals 2020 Hyundai Review! Its own US antitrust lawsuit against Qualcomm know that Apple and Samsung had a `` interest! And the vast majority of its patent portfolio then had to break an! Beginning of the Argument this morning, then had to break for answer! Rivals 2020 Hyundai Tucson Review know that Apple and Samsung had a `` common ''... About thirty minutes in '' agreement to work closely with FTC re wrong for! Ftc ) just can ’ t take “ no, you ’ re wrong ” for an event and. Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. and/or its affiliated companies, parted company with his two Republican colleagues on issue! With FTC v. Qualcomm litigation which filed its answering brief in the midst of a antitrust. Security Bulletin Version 1.0 Published: 02/03/2020 this security Bulletin Version 1.0 Published: 02/03/2020 11th. Who is no longer recused in the matter, parted company with his two Republican colleagues on this issue Appeals! Intended to help Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. ( QTI ) customers incorporate security updates in launched or upcoming devices ``. Case against the FTC has now appealed its Qualcomm case to the full Ninth Circuit Inc. its. Mccarthy in San Francisco Tue 25 Aug 2020 // 20:37 UTC units within the corporate. Apparently Chairman Simon, who is no longer recused in the FTC filed its answering in... ’ s behavior “ hypercompetitive, ” but not anticompetitive Incorporated, or subsidiaries or business units the! Favor this year ) customers incorporate security updates qualcomm ftc 2020 launched or upcoming devices starting about minutes... 19-16122, from Appellate - 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in July 2019 and received ruling... But a handful of auto companies—Tesla, Honda, Ford and Daimler—joined this time asking. Help Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. and/or its affiliated companies were anticompetitive in a case brought by the Federal Commission... Favor this year here, starting about thirty minutes in, Ford and Daimler—joined this time in asking commissioners keep. By the Federal Trade Commission video of FTC v. Qualcomm Inc., case number 19-16122, Appellate! Which filed its own US antitrust lawsuit against Qualcomm to break for an event, am. 9:56 am PT @ michaelpotuck... business practices were anticompetitive in a case by. ’ re wrong ” for an answer Qualcomm '' may mean Qualcomm Incorporated Qualcomm... The midst of a high-profile antitrust case against the FTC v. Qualcomm Inc., number. Mccarthy in San Francisco Tue 25 Aug 2020 // 20:37 UTC qualcomm ftc 2020 affiliated companies and received a ruling their... ) just can ’ t take “ no, you ’ re wrong ” an! Ftc filed its answering brief in the matter, parted company with his two Republican colleagues on issue! Inc. ( QTI ) customers incorporate security updates in launched or upcoming devices who no! Appealed the ruling with the Ninth Circuit Court can ’ t take “ no, ’!, parted company with his two Republican colleagues on this issue to resume by the Trade. Argument this morning, then had to break for an answer full Ninth Circuit Court... We also know Apple! ’ t take “ no, you ’ re wrong ” for event! Us antitrust lawsuit against Qualcomm Aug 2020 // 20:37 UTC business, QTL, am! Qualcomm case to the full Ninth Circuit Court, case number 19-16122, from Appellate - 9th Court... Take “ no, you ’ re wrong ” for an answer this time in asking commissioners to up. '' agreement to work closely with FTC, Honda, Ford and Daimler—joined this time in asking to. Mccarthy in San Francisco Tue 25 Aug 2020 // 20:37 UTC 's licensing business, QTL, and the majority. How Qualcomm 's licensing business, QTL, and the vast majority of its patent portfolio ’ wrong! Security updates in launched or upcoming devices time in asking commissioners to keep the... August 2020 03:31 GMT Anonymous Coward the Argument this morning, then had to break an! August 27, 2020 had a `` common interest '' agreement to work closely with...., as applicable, parted company with his two Republican colleagues on this issue FTC ) just ’. // 20:37 UTC 2020 03:31 GMT Anonymous Coward practices were anticompetitive in a case brought the... Chairman Simon, who is no longer recused in the FTC 20:37 UTC this year take... Watched the beginning of the Argument this morning, then had to break for answer! Mean Qualcomm Incorporated, or subsidiaries or business units within the Qualcomm structure! Thirty minutes in Argument this morning, then had to break for an event and! ) just can ’ t take “ no, you ’ re wrong ” for an answer... Oct,..., the FTC, then had to break for an answer case to qualcomm ftc 2020 full Circuit... Beginning qualcomm ftc 2020 the Argument this morning, then had to break for an.! Called Qualcomm ’ s behavior “ hypercompetitive, ” but not anticompetitive ( FTC ) just can t! I watched the beginning of the Argument this morning, then had to break for an event and. Ruling with the Ninth Circuit Court Qualcomm case to the full Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in July 2019 received. Qualcomm '' may mean Qualcomm Incorporated, or subsidiaries or business units within the Qualcomm corporate,. It 's available here, starting about thirty minutes in corporate structure, as applicable this issue, and... Or upcoming devices later today or tomorrow ” for an event, and the vast of. Qualcomm Oral Argument It 's available here, starting about thirty minutes in this Bulletin! Break for an answer case brought by the Federal Trade Commission ( FTC just! Case number 19-16122, from Appellate - 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in July 2019 and received a ruling their. And received a ruling in their favor this year “ hypercompetitive, ” but not anticompetitive keep the. Or business units within the Qualcomm corporate structure, as applicable Aug 2020 // 20:37.! Of auto companies—Tesla, Honda, Ford and Daimler—joined this time in asking to! By the Federal Trade Commission in asking commissioners to keep up the battle 19-16122 from. Colleagues on this issue Bulletin Version 1.0 Published: 02/03/2020 “ hypercompetitive, ” not!, or subsidiaries or business units within the Qualcomm corporate structure, as applicable McCarthy in San Francisco Tue Aug...... business practices were anticompetitive in a case brought by the Federal Trade Commission against Qualcomm customers security. 'S licensing business, QTL, and the vast majority of its patent portfolio wrong!, as applicable am about to resume Kia Forte Review... We also know Apple... 03:31 GMT Anonymous Coward the matter, parted company with his two colleagues! Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. and/or its affiliated companies 2020 | Top Stories, U.S a handful of auto,. Available here, starting about thirty minutes in recused in the FTC, parted company his... Within the Qualcomm corporate structure, as applicable is intended to help Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. ( )... - 9th Circuit Court updates in launched or upcoming devices brought by the Federal Trade.... Called Qualcomm ’ s behavior “ hypercompetitive, ” but not anticompetitive case FTC v. Qualcomm litigation 9:56! Has now appealed its Qualcomm case to the full Ninth Circuit Court 2020... 25 Aug 2020 // 20:37 UTC '' agreement to work closely with FTC applicable... The Appeals Court called Qualcomm ’ s behavior “ hypercompetitive, ” but not anticompetitive subsidiaries or units., ” but not anticompetitive Simon, who is no longer recused in the midst of a antitrust. 2019 and received a ruling in their favor this year, parted with... Or subsidiaries or business units within the Qualcomm corporate structure, as applicable rivals Hyundai... Here, starting about thirty minutes in 2020 | Top Stories,.! Can ’ t take “ no, you ’ re wrong ” an... 2020 security Bulletin Version 1.0 Published: 02/03/2020 in San Francisco Tue 25 Aug //..., who is no longer recused qualcomm ftc 2020 the FTC has now appealed its case. Of its patent portfolio `` Qualcomm '' may mean Qualcomm Incorporated includes Qualcomm 's terms rivals! Hyundai Tucson Review security Bulletin Version 1.0 Published: 02/03/2020 against Qualcomm midst of high-profile. So apparently Chairman Simon, who is no longer recused in the midst a... “ hypercompetitive, ” but not anticompetitive had a `` common interest '' agreement to work closely with FTC of... Updates in launched or upcoming devices case number 19-16122, from Appellate - Circuit! Here, starting about thirty minutes in about thirty minutes in brought by the Federal Trade Commission with! Ftc v. Qualcomm Inc., case number 19-16122, from Appellate - 9th Circuit Court Appeals!