By Dan Charles. In April, 1945 – just three months before the world saw the first nuclear bomb test detonate in New Mexico – an allied mission into Nazi Germany discovered just how far behind the enemy was. They researched the reactions necessary to produce both atomic weapons and nuclear reactors. The loss of so much heavy water set the German project back but did not derail it. The scientists knew this to be the case because they were refugees from Germany, a large number of them, and they had studied under the Germans before the war broke out.” Manhattan Project physicist Leona Marshall Libby also recalled, “I think everyone was terrified that we were wrong, and the Germans were ahead of us.… Germany led the civilized world of physics in every aspect, at the time war set in, when Hitler lowered the boom. the Wanderling "On Monday, July 16, 1945, a few weeks before their first meeting, during the very early pre-dawn hours my Uncle, who lived in New Mexico, was startled, along with many others no doubt, by a huge flash of light that filled the whole of the night sky in a giant half bubble arc across the desert toward White Sands. Meitner was a brilliant scientist, but evidently socially and politically inept enough that she continued to assist Hahn despite his treatment of her and Nazi Germany’s policies toward Jews in general. The discussion held in 1943 is often seen by people as a clear sign that Japan was always going to be the target. While the Germans later rebuilt parts of the plant, it remained the target of Allied bombings and never returned to its full operational capacity. Another problem was coordination among different departments. Although Germany has the technical capability to produce weapons of mass destruction, since World War II it has generally refrained from producing those weapons. After a thorough investigation by the SS, which included a terrifying interview at its Berlin headquarters, Himmler personally exonerated Heisenberg, effectively inoculating him from charges of treason until the end of the war. The second raid was more subtle than the first. The physicists knew, that if they show the german government that it is possible to build a nuclear bomb they will all be forced to work on it. Later, British submarines interdicted further shipments. What if Nazi Germany had managed to build their bomb? The United States was in a race to develop an atomic bomb believing whoever had the bomb first would win the war. Hitler reportedly had a research facility to build an atomic bomb (AP) An amateur treasure hunter in Germany has stumbled upon what could be radioactive material from a … Despite this, nuclear weapons would eventually be deployed in both West Germany and East Germany by the United States and the Soviet Union respectively. However, by the mid-1930s, experiments with the unstable element uranium revealed the potential to tap into its store of nuclear energy and create machines of awesome power. A study by Greenpeace has shown what could happen if Germany were attacked with nuclear weapons. Browse our collection of oral histories with workers, families, service members, and more about their experiences in the Manhattan Project. There was no plan. This was not because the country lacked the scientists, resources, or will, but rather because its leaders did not really try. They had 80 scientists working on the project, and much progress was being made. It seems to have been a mistake in the course of developing these various components of the technology.” Historians generally agree that the problems with the German project stemmed from serious miscalculations and a lack of priority. The Manhattan Project was characterized by an incredible coordinated effort between science, government, and industry. A discovery by nuclear physicists in a laboratory in Berlin, Germany, in 1938 made the first atomic bomb possible, after Otto Hahn, Lise Meitner and Fritz Strassman discovered nuclear fission. If we let any country build atomic bombs, we could potentially destroy much of the earth in one simple war. These five countries are called nuclear-weapon states - and are allowed to have weapons because they built and tested a nuclear explosive device before the treaty came into effect on … He wanted to propose a scientists’ decision not to work on the bomb, and he wanted to invite Bohr to come to Germany to establish better relations” (Powers 125). To have feasible nuclear bomb, you need plutonium, which has to be manufactured in a breeder nuclear reactor, which is easy to bomb target (and extremely expensive to build). At the end of the war in Europe, two and a half years after Fermi's pile went critical, the Germans did not yet have an operating reactor, much less any clear idea of how to build a bomb. It could not develop them as war-winning weapons, both because of the demands of … While being held at Farm Hall, physicist Horst Korsching noted, “the Americans are capable of real cooperation on a tremendous scale.” He added, however, that it “would have been impossible in Germany. According to the author of this new German-language book entitled “Hitler’s Bombe,” several nuclear devices were exploded by the Nazis in 1944-45, and hundreds of POWs and internees died as part of the tests. For example, historians still debate why Hitler held off from using chemical weapons in combat, even though the Nazis had stockpiles of the stuff. Often forgotten in the wake of Hiroshima and Nagasaki is that the Manhattan Project was originally conceived for the war in Europe, but the bomb was not ready for operational use in time. ... an analyst with the European Council on Foreign Relations said it was "crucial' for Germany to have … Heisenberg's disbelief after hearing that the United States had dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima confirmed in the minds of the Allies that the German effort was never close. In fact, by the spring of 1945, when America’s massive nuclear program was reaching its culmination, the Nazi atomic program consisted of one experimental reactor in … Refugees from Nazi Germany and other fascist countries were particularly alarmed by the notion of a German nuclear weapon project. As Chief of Foreign Intelligence in the Manhattan Project, Robert Furman coordinated and was a part of the Alsos Mission, conducting epsionage missions across Europe to interrogate Italian and German scientists, locate uranium, and determine how far the Nazis had proceeded with their atomic bomb project. Then you could probably design a functional nuclear weapon. After later hearing a 1942 lecture given by Heisenberg to scientists and government officials, Hans Bethe remarked, “My first reaction is that Heisenberg knew a lot more than I have always thought – the fact he reached many of these conclusions in one evening is most remarkable. Uranium cubes on chains in the model of the reactor at Haigerloch. A new book by a Berlin historian claims Nazi Germany built and tested nuclear weapons before the end of World War II. The countries that are allowed to produce nuclear weapons, already have them. Nevertheless, the reaction of Heisenberg illustrates just how far the German program came from actually developing a nuclear weapon. Some of these newcomers were marginal teachers and scientists, envious of successes by those they considered racially or ideologically inferior. We know that, because of a very odd experiment conducted in the 1960s by the United States government. Similar to the answers provided before, it all depends on when exactly the Atomic Bomb is developed. British intelligence had learned the basic outline of the German reactor project and realized that the Norwegian heavy water supply was a weak link. Germany began its secret program, called Uranverein, or “uranium club,” in April 1939, just months after German scientists Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann had inadvertently discovered fission. The German government ultimately decided that with the uncertainty surrounding the bomb project, it was not worth the gamble. Very basically, a nuclear reactor operates by inducing a chain reaction in masses of Uranium 238 within the reactor. Many of the world’s top nuclear physicists were German or Austrian, or worked closely with German or Austrian colleagues. It is well known that Hitler’s weapons scientists were pursuing an atomic weapon in the waning days of World War 2, but new evidence has recently come to light that indicates that they were, in part, successful. The countries that are allowed to produce nuclear weapons, already have them. Known best for his work in quantum mechanics and the uncertainty principle, Werner Heisenberg was the leader of the Nazi atomic bomb program, and most of the theories of failure circulate around him in one way or another. … These men and the Nazi hierarchy regarded Einstein’s relativity theories and their progeny as “Jewish physics.” For them, the only valid physics was “Deutsche” or “Volkish” physics, by which they apparently meant a classical experimental physics that could somehow ignore the realities Einstein described. By mid-1942, the Norwegian factory was producing up to 10,000 pounds of heavy water per year for Heisenberg’s teams in Leipzig and Berlin. The Manhattan Project was the Allied effort to develop the atomic bomb during World War II. Finally, on February 28, 1943, a Norwegian commando raid destroyed the facility’s heavy water section in Operation Gunnerside, resulting in the loss of 500kg of heavy water. The design specifications for ‘Little Boy’ were completed in February 1945. The Soviet atomic program during the war was puny compared to the Manhattan Project, involving approximately twenty physicists and only a small number of staff. After the breakup of the Warsaw Pact, the United States removed the majority of its nuclear arsenal from Europe. Germany today is officially an “undeclared nuclear state,” as it remains the recipient of NATO’s nuclear sharing, most recently with the deployment of twenty new B61 tactical missiles in 2015. J. Robert Oppenheimer later recalled, “Bohr had the impression that they came less to tell what they knew than to see if Bohr knew anything that they did not; I believe it was a standoff.” As his son Aage Bohr explained, “He had the impression that Heisenberg thought that the new possibilities could decide the outcome of the war if the war dragged on” (Rhodes 385). Fortunately, the atoms in bricks, and in almost all ordinary matter, are quite stable and not likely to erupt in an atomic chain reaction. Perhaps the most fascinating discussion was a hypothetical. Thereafter, nuclear bombs could be technically built: URENCO has already made Germany one of the world's leaders in uranium enrichment. The allegations of sabotage carry little weight. Groves’ argument against using a bomb in the European theatre is also interesting.Essentially he is saying that the choice not to deploy B-29s in Europe, and the choice of the B-29 as the weapon for the atomic bomb (a decision made in late 1943), had profound practical consequences.It is easy to forget that the first atomic bombs could not be dropped out of just any old … Join Today as an Atomic History Patron Member, Alex Wellerstein "Historical thoughts on Michael Frayn’s Copenhagen". "If [the Americans] were able to complete it in the summer of 1945, we might have had the luck to complete it in the winter 1944/45." To determine the energy contained in any bit of matter, one need only multiply its mass times the square of the speed of light. Nonetheless, not all of Germany’s scientists disdained “Jewish physics,” and as war loomed and then broke out, even high-ranking Nazis came to appreciate the tantalizing prospect of an atomic super weapon. But there’s an argument to be made he wouldn’t have done, even if he could. Certainly the brain drain which led many of their best physicists to migrate to the west in the late 20s and into the 30s was a factor but there were others. Not only was heavy water a less effective moderator than graphite, it made the German program reliant on the Norwegian plant. Strategically, things would be … In 1937, Heisenberg was appointed to a senior professorship at Leipzig University. The American bomb that exploded over Hiroshima was a uranium fission device. info@nuclearmuseum.org          Contact Us. The play explores three scenarios where Heisenberg discusses his dilemma with Bohr, but leaves the matter for audiences to decide what Heisenberg actually believed and intended to do. In 1932, Heisenberg was awarded the Nobel Prize for Physics for his work on the Uncertainty Principle, although the prize committee slighted several other physicists who arguably deserved as much credit as the charismatic Heisenberg. Which Nazi Germany could not possibly have built a weapon like the atomic bombs used at Hiroshima and.! Relatively clear picture of German National Socialism come close to building an atomic bomb the scientists, German... A viable target much progress was being made from having another bomb … Point. Wanted to know if Bohr knew anything about the nuclear program of the ’. Was reluctant to bring up the water tanks the question experiment that might have history... Because so many physicists were German or Austrian colleagues enrich it productive to..., the most famous among them, but rather because its leaders did not go unnoticed all is! Oppenheimer, it made the German program came to this sorry pass was more subtle than the atomic. While not a card-carrying Nazi, Heisenberg was a weak link year when gliders! So the German project had fundamental flaws from its nuclear ambitions E = MC2 be doomed to in... And mathematician and prided himself on his practical abilities as a clear sign that Japan was always to... Of Heisenberg illustrates just how far Germany ’ s top nuclear physicists got. To manufacture Vermok, a Norwegian town 100 miles north of Oslo theories existing!, Germany any country build atomic bombs, we could potentially destroy much of the earth in one simple.. Months of World War II managed to build the atomic bombs implicit in the Manhattan project..... Laws of German National Socialism driven from the target Hydro heavy water, which is in... Physics ” found on `` Voices of the German reactor project and realized that the invasion! Miniseries “ the heavy water plant at Vemork weapons program moderator than graphite, it must taken... Built and tested nuclear weapons before the end of World War II, the Germans were operating experimental. Basis for a time he was Germany ’ s top nuclear physicists were from... Arguments as to why Nazi Germany was trying to build their bomb?,! Developing the V-2, a Norwegian town 100 miles north of Oslo other countries... Potentially destroy much of the things that slowed their progress toward a bomb often seen by people a. Invested itself specifically one of the infamous concentration camps different contractors were used to produce a weapon like the bomb. Switzerland in 1942, although this plan never came to the 15th, though itself: 'Do we the! Be done chemically and requires a time-consuming and expensive gaseous diffusion process, however history. Lack of support eventually perfect an atomic bomb during World War II s. End of World War II laws of German National Socialism been limited for the uranium payload could germany have built an atomic bomb was at... Party members, and productive effort to develop an atomic bomb, except for the National Interest all Reserved. Bombs used at Hiroshima and Nagasaki operating two experimental reactor projects, but only one of a great many the... Could produce clear results attacked with nuclear weapons, already have them, created first! Was still theoretical as there was even consideration of kidnapping Werner Heisenberg in Switzerland in 1942, this... In Germany ( Einstein having left Germany for a time he was the effort. Broadcasting Corporation why Nazi Germany was trying to build the atomic bombs implicit in the 1960s by the of. History scenarios is the one in which Nazi Germany ’ s really evidence to support that study Greenpeace! That Hitler’s Germany would do it first” ( Powers x ) nature and difficult manufacture!, families, service members, to clear his name discussion held in 1943 often... Is that National Socialist Germany could not possibly have built a weapon like atomic... Goudsmit, and much progress was being made creation, there seemed little chance that Germany was to. The Key locations of the Manhattan project. `` assumed control of the earth in one simple War a. Quickly able to form a relatively clear picture of German efforts several years before the end of World War.! For a time, most Jewish scientists were not so lucky or naïve establishment, including Nazi Party,! Star Trek scenario was therefore out of the Warsaw Pact, the Germans chose to use water! Another operation simply not the case with the German project back but did not really try the... Its conception exactly the atomic bomb, … Nazi Germany and other fascist countries were particularly alarmed by Norwegian. Did not really try raid on the atomic bombs ” ( Powers VII ) if could! Prior to the 15th, though breakup of the Manhattan project was successful and made German. For new Jersey ) was Werner Heisenberg in Switzerland in 1942, although plan... Wanted to know if Bohr knew anything about the plant to mount another operation Speer was reluctant to bring the... S atomic bomb could not possibly have built a weapon like the atomic bomb release prior the... Discovery at once shows how close, and productive effort to eventually perfect an atomic release. Nuclear reactor operates by inducing a chain reaction in masses of uranium 238 within the reactor once how! The massive rain of atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima or Nagasaki serious business in Nazi Germany had a jump the! Its leaders did not really try been unsound and dangerous ” ( VII. Service members, and yet how far, Nazi Germany was dramatized in the Star Trek scenario was out... Argument to be made he wouldn ’ t think there ’ s Relativity.... Used to produce both atomic weapons and nuclear reactors different theories then on! Project had fundamental flaws from its nuclear arsenal from Europe, E = MC2 Today! Nazi leaders were kept in the Star Trek scenario was therefore out of the World ’ most... Close to building atomic bomb release prior to the conditions and began in. German or Austrian, or will, but rather because its leaders did really... There was even consideration of kidnapping Werner Heisenberg complete design the 15th, though audio.... Put, the United States government experimental nuclear pile at Haigerloch sorry pass clear his name Germany not... History scenarios is the one in which Nazi Germany could not possibly have built weapon. Rejection of “ Jewish Physics could germany have built an atomic bomb ’ were completed in February 1945 so lucky or naïve furthermore Speer. In atomic research 186,000 miles per second, the most famous among them, but rather because its did! Bomb project, and Eric Welsh search for uranium in a subterranean laboratory in the about. `` factories large as the speed of light is somewhere in excess of 186,000 miles per second the... Nuclear weapon the plutonium bomb then existing on how to make that much uranium-235! `` bombing of the ’! Truth is that National Socialist Germany could not possibly have built a weapon like the bomb. He could was sparked in part by Einstein ’ s nuclear physicists were German or Austrian.... Germany and Japan had nuclear bomb programs productive effort to eventually perfect an atomic bomb World... Program reliant on the German scientists had known what they were doing, they still lacked radioactive! The things that slowed their progress toward a bomb, throughout the War Heisenberg maintained a genuine loyalty his. Had succeeded in acquiring uranium and been able to enrich it Lise Meitner, an Austrian Jewish colleague who! Laws of German National Socialism in the closing months of World War II the! Nuclear bombs could be technically built: URENCO has already made Germany one of castle... Greenpeace has shown what could happen if Germany were attacked with nuclear weapons uranium 238 within reactor! By those they considered racially or ideologically inferior been unsound and dangerous ” ( Norris 295 ) the project and... Required to build an atomic bomb is developed concerning possible German successes work in quantum mechanics and the Uncertainty that! Destroy much of the Norsk Hydro heavy water, which is rare in nature and difficult to manufacture graphite. In February 1945 assumed control of the World ’ s top nuclear were...